Welcome to The Mental Arena, a newsletter where I share mental performance tools and pressure-tested insights to help you build confidence, strengthen your focus, and develop the mindset to win—in sport and life.

Forwarded this email? Sign up here.

Challenge or Threat: Which Game Are You Playing?

read time 3 minutes

Pressure introduces you to yourself.

When the game tightens and the noise rises, the story you tell yourself decides what happens next. Some shrink. Some surge. The difference isn’t talent or toughness; it’s perception.

Pressure has two paths.

One pulls you forward. The other locks you in place.

The Research Behind the Response

Performance psychology refers to this as the Theory of Challenge and Threat States in Athletes.

The principle is simple: your body follows your appraisal. The way you see a moment determines how you prepare for it.

Researchers tracked athletes, soldiers, and business professionals as they performed under pressure. They weren’t studying skills; they were studying perception.

Two distinct responses consistently emerged: Challenge and Threat.

Those who viewed pressure as a challenge showed physical markers of readiness. Their hearts pumped blood efficiently. Blood vessels stayed open. Focus expanded, energy aligned with what the task required.

Those who viewed pressure as a threat exhibited defensive behavior. Vessels constricted. Cortisol spiked. Decision-making slowed. Their attention tunneled to what might go wrong instead of what needed to go right.

Same circumstance. Different interpretation. Entirely different outcome.

Across more than 7,000 participants, the trend held true: those who saw pressure as a test of capability—not an attack on identity—performed better.
(Moore et al., The Effects of Challenge and Threat States on Performance Outcomes, 2021)

That’s the science. But here’s what it means in real life:

Your brain and body are in constant conversation. When the mind labels a moment as danger, the body prepares to protect. When the mind labels it as a challenge, the body prepares to perform.

Threat says, “Survive this.”
Challenge says, “Meet this.”

That one mental shift triggers a cascade inside you.
​
It redirects your thoughts, steadies your emotions, and rewires how your body prepares to perform.

Mental Lesson: The Challenge Lens

Mental strength lives in the gap between belief and response.

A challenge mindset sounds like: “This is hard, but I’m capable.” It sharpens focus, channels energy, and organizes effort.

A threat mindset sounds like: “This might go wrong.” It fragments focus and builds tension instead of rhythm.

The difference starts with honest appraisal:
“Here’s what I’m capable of. Here’s what the moment demands. I’m going to meet it with everything I’ve trained to do.”

You can hear this clarity in every great performer:
​“I’ve guarded this action all season. Stay square. I’m ready.”​
​“I’ve prepared for this moment. The game needs composure. Watch me set the tone.”​
​“I know my material. This room needs clarity and confidence. Let my preparation speak.”

That’s the internal language of self-trust.

Next Rep: Train Your Appraisal

Pressure will show up this week: in practice, in meetings, in conversations that matter.

When it does, take 30 seconds to train your appraisal:

1. Map the demand. What is being asked of me right now?
2. Match the resources. What skills, preparation, or mindset can I apply?
3. Make the choice. Meet this moment as a challenge. Engage fully and compete.

It’s a small mental pivot with a big physical effect.

Appraisal is a muscle. The more you train it, the faster your system calibrates for performance.

Final Buzzer

A challenge state is more than a mindset shift; it’s a full-body recalibration.

When you see a moment as a challenge, your system organizes around opportunity. Heart rate rises, but rhythm steadies. Focus narrows, but clarity expands. You move in sync with what’s being asked and what you’ve trained to deliver.

Adrenaline becomes fuel. Uncertainty turns to engagement. Pressure transforms from a weight to a signal—a reminder that you’re exactly where growth happens.

Pressure reveals readiness. It magnifies habits, focus, and self-trust. It’s not testing your worth; it’s awakening it.

So the next time the moment tightens, when your breath shortens and the noise builds, remember: your body follows your story. The narrative you tell inside becomes the performance you deliver.

Challenging you head-on and always in your corner,
​— Coach VJ

Thanks for reading. Your next issue of The Mental Arena drops September 30.

Upcoming Speaking Events:

Am I coming to a city near you? Let me know!
​
November 1 - Featherville, Idaho
November 3-4 - Pocatello, Idaho (ISU Athletics)
November 19-20 - Pocatello, Idaho (ISU Athletics)
March 5 - Pocatello, Idaho ('26) (ISU Athletics)
March 20-21 - Arlington, Virginia ('26)
March 27-28 - Springfield, Massachusetts ('26)

Interested in bringing me in to speak to your team or organization?
​Request an event or shoot an email to support@mentalitysolutions.com to get on the schedule.

Resources:

The Confidence Blueprint Online Course